The Short Answer
Whether bankruptcy lowers your house or car payment depends on which chapter you file. Neither Chapter 7 nor Chapter 13 can lower your mortgage payment — you'll need to keep paying it as contracted or surrender the home. Your car payment is a different story: in Chapter 13, if you've owned your vehicle for more than 910 days (about 2½ years) before filing and owe more than it's worth, you may be able to "cram down" the loan balance to the car's current market value, potentially reducing your payment significantly.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x5ZXRGROQd0
Depending on which bankruptcy you file, bankruptcy may lower your monthly payments for a car but will not lower your payments for a house. A Chapter 7 bankruptcy will not lower your monthly payments but you will be wiping out all of your other debts and will no longer be charged interest and late fees on those payments. Therefore, you free up more money each month which helps your ability to make your car or house payments each month. If you still feel like there is no way that you would be able to afford to make the payment each month, then you can surrender your vehicle or house and wipe out any mortgage or car loan that is left over.
In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, once you file, your secured creditors will want you to sign what’s known as a reaffirmation agreement. A reaffirmation agreement tells that creditor that you will continue to make your payments as contracted. In a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, you are not required to sign a reaffirmation agreement on your home, but you must sign one in order to retain your vehicle. In either case, you must continue to make your monthly payments, and upon default, they have the right to foreclose or repossess the property. Now, there are some cases in which you can redeem your car instead of reaffirming it, but you will need to discuss this with your attorney.
In a Chapter 13 bankruptcy, the trustee will be making your house and vehicle payment through the bankruptcy plan. As with a Chapter 7 bankruptcy, your mortgage payment will be the same as it was before you filed the bankruptcy. There is no way to “get around” this unless you refinance your home, in which you will need to obtain permission from the court to do so once you have filed the bankruptcy. If your vehicle is over 910 days (2 ½ years) before the date that you filed the bankruptcy, you may be able to do what’s known as a “cramdown”. If your loan balance is higher than what your vehicle is worth (the court will usually determine the value based upon NADA), then you can pay back the vehicle based upon what it is worth rather than the contracted loan balance. This option is only available in a Chapter 13 bankruptcy though. If it was purchased within the 2 ½ years before you filed, you will pay back the amount that is contracted in your Chapter 13 plan.
Therefore, bankruptcy may lower your car payment through a “cramdown”. However, it you will not be able to lower your monthly house payment through a bankruptcy. If you are behind on your house payment you could potentially file a Chapter 13 bankruptcy which will help you pay back the arrearages, or amount owed, but it will not actually lower your mortgage payment.
Key Takeaways
- Bankruptcy cannot lower your monthly mortgage payment — your only options are to keep paying as contracted, catch up arrears through a Chapter 13 plan, or surrender the home and discharge the remaining balance.
- A Chapter 13 "cramdown" can reduce your car loan balance to the vehicle's NADA market value, but only if the loan is more than 910 days old at the time you file.
- In Chapter 7, you must sign a reaffirmation agreement to keep your vehicle — without it, the lender can repossess even if you're current on payments.
- Chapter 7 does not lower car or house payments directly, but eliminating unsecured debts frees up monthly cash that can make those payments more manageable.
- If you can't afford your car or house payment even after bankruptcy, you can surrender the property and wipe out any remaining deficiency balance.
- Refinancing your mortgage while in an active Chapter 13 requires court approval before you can proceed.
Attorney Insight
The cramdown is one of the most underused tools in Chapter 13, and people come in all the time not realizing they qualify. I've had clients paying $600 a month on a truck worth half what they owe — after a cramdown, their plan payment on that vehicle drops dramatically. The 910-day rule is the key: if you financed that car more than 2½ years before your filing date, we can base repayment on actual value, not the inflated loan balance. On the mortgage side, I always make sure clients understand upfront that Chapter 13 is a powerful tool for stopping a foreclosure and catching up arrears — but it won't shrink the payment itself, so the math has to work on your income before we file.
